Start of a Memorable Trip

Start of a Memorable Trip

Thursday, July 15, 2010

My Thoughts about Today (by Kim)


I can say with certainty that I had one of the most interesting days of my life exploring the Jewish quarter with Mark, my husband of 25 years and Alex, our guide.

On the way to the former Jewish quarter, Alex pointed out a memorial in front of the Berlin Symphony Orchestra House, which was erected to commemorate Hitler's plan to rid the Aryans of mentally and physically challenged people, called the T 4 plan. It is two S shaped granite columns. The memorial is perfect and symmetrical in design and is a nice way to pay homage to people who are imperfect.

In the former Jewish section, there are small gold (or perhaps brass?) plaques, placed discreetly in the sidewalk in front of individual homes. I thought this was such a meaningful way to remember the Jewish people, whose name, date of birth and where and when they were murdered, is inscribed on each plaque. Alex waited for one of us, and it happened to be Mark, to stumble on the first plaque. I thought the significance of this was that people carried on their lives in Berlin hardly noticing that their Jewish neighbours were disappearing from around them. Of course once we saw the first plaque, then we started to see the others.

I particularly liked hearing about how the women of Rosenstrazse protested when their husbands were imprisoned. The memorial is on the sight of the Old Synagogue, which was destroyed on Kristallnacht. The stones show the women pleading for their husbands' lives. Four weeks later the men were released.

We also visited Otto Weitz's workshop where he sheltered Jews in his workshop for the blind. They made brushes, which were in demand during the war. Otto Weitz personally went to rescue his Jewish secretary from Auschwitz. He successfully arranged for her escape.

I thought it was so neat the way the whole area has become a hip artist's area, full of boutiques and cheap former East Bloc housing for hippies. Berlin is a thriving living memorial to the dead. It is also a good tourist trap as I saw some interesting fashion by avant garde designers.

I am now consumed by wanting to read Holocaust literature. I took several pamphlets from Otto Weitz's shop. As well, Mark bought an excellent book at Terezienstadt by a survivor.

We stopped for a pastry. Mark to provide details. Alex told us that the owner made bread for the deportation camps as well as challah on Friday nights. The bakery also survived during communism. The bakery is still owned by the daughter, now in her eighties, of the original owner.

Alex also showed us the New Synagogue. Miraculously it was not destroyed on Kristallnacht. A policeman, Krutzfeld, warned the caretaker of the impending pogrom. The son of the caretaker, who survived the war, revealed this later. The Nazis used the synagogue to store their records of who was Jewish, half Jewish etc. They remain because the Nazis filled in the ceiling of the shul with rubble so that if it was bombed the rubble would stop the total destruction. They also threw some artifacts into the ceiling, like the Aron Kodesh which we saw.

We ended our day at the wonderful Jewish Museum. Libeskind's architecture is so thoughtful and I particularly liked his depiction of emigration from Berlin by having the visitor walk through the pathways of columns, which are built on a slope. Thus creating the feeling of losing one's footing in a new country. The museum is not a Holocaust museum. It focuses on German Jewish life from medieval times to the present day collapse of the wall and the current social political life of German Jewry. It is more about education and understanding. I think non-Jews would find it particularly enlightening.

There is a tower depicting the Holocaust. The visitor stands in the enclosed space in near darkness.

In our tours in general of Berlin, Alex keeps pointing out evidence of the wall. We saw today a huge area of grass which was a no man's land. Yesterday we saw how this no man's land was turned into a beach along the Spree river. Because the wall only came down in 1988, Berlin is full of exciting new buildings and the architecture is very futuristic. Potsdam Square (Potsdamer Platz) and the fabulous Mis van Der Roe National Art Gallery are examples of this. In contrast some of the former Eastern Bloc housing still stands.

At the end of a tiring and interesting day, we found a delightful local restaurant where we ate an Italian meal with people who obviously live in the neighbourhood and were stopping by after work with their wives or friends for a simple meal. I was reading one of the pamphlets I had taken today, but found myself hiding the title about Jewish Resistance during the war.

Dinner Report


Fagiano really was good and comes with the satisfaction of having found it oursleves. And, no, tonight we did not have dessert.

My favourite information from all that we learned today is the fact that the Nazi closure of the clothing trade meant there was a shortage of lederhausen.

Today there were some labour disruptions at many German airports resulting in the cancellation of many domestic flights. While no international flights were cancelled, we have to connect in Frankfurt to get home so I'm hoping there isn't anything to worry about for Saturday. Not much we can do about it anyway...

An Observation


We are again in a residential west end area apart from the tourists. There are lots of restaurants and this time of year, as at home, the locals relish the opportunity to sit outside. Also, as at home, Italian is very popular. What is very different though is the relatively large number of smokers. There is almost one per table. On that note my salad with fresh mushrooms just arrived. Kim ordered the special pasta with the same mushrooms (but switched the sauce from cream to tomato) and I ordered fegato a la veneziano. The special dessert is profiteroles.

Photo is of our hotel at night.

What's for Dinner?

We didn't have a plan so strolled locally and have settled on Italian at Fagiano. Starving so hope it's good!

Jewish Museum


The new museum opened in 2001. Daniel Libeskind built it to add to the existing museum. The new part is a zigzag form. Perhaps it is a broken Star of David? It is open to interpretation. There also are various empty spaces with an obvious interpretation.

We went through the "Axis of Exile" showing the various places where those who were able to flee went to. The area I built on an incline which shows the difficulty getting out.

There were outdoor columns built in an incline do it is unstable to walk there. The area is the Garden of Exile.

The Axis of the Holocaust leads to a tower. As you walk along there is no warning as to what is coming.

The museum covers 2,000 years of history and can't be absorbed in one visit. Our plan was to focus mainly on the modern era including the Holocaust period but my highlights that follow show that we took in quite a bit more.

The Axis of Continuity cuts through the space and leads up to the exhibition. The early portion discusses medieval times and various religious and secular restrictions which regulated how Jews could live. They weren't citizens, had to pay "body taxes" and basically were kept out of things like agriculture and the trades and forced into things like banking.
We can't summarize the exhibition, but one thing of note was the story of Levi's Jeans. Levi Strauss was the youngest son of Rebecca Strauss who emigrated to the US in 1847 with her three youngest children. She left rural Germany where Jews were heavily regulated in terms of what they could do to survive.

Moses Mendelssohn embraced the European Enlightenment and, as mentioned in a post earlier today, introduced secular and modern education into Jewish education. He became a leading figure of the Enlightenment. He also translated the Torah into German. The flip side was to spread German culture among Jews. He wanted Jews to be fully integrated into German life with language as an essential first step. As such he was both an important progressive Jew and an important figure in the German Enlightenment.

(The risks of blogging while walking-I just smashed my toes against a step I wasn't expecting, and I'm wearing sandals.)

Home movies of family life from the '30's by one family looked like home movies I've seen of my own family. The family shown in what I'm viewing moved to Palestine (as it then was) and then to California.

Other parts of the exhibition illustrated the increasing assimilation and secularization of the community such as table ware showing non-observance with dietary laws.


By the mid-19th century certain things remained closed to Jews but some professions became open. Still, popular stereotypes notwithstanding, most lived at or below subsistence despite new opportunities.

Albert Rosenhain founded a leather goods company. "A Rosenhain wallet fits in every pants pocket.". The Nazis liquidated the company in 1938.

One exhibit showed some extensive family trees.

There is an extensive section on 19th century life including racially based (as opposed to religiously based) anti-Semitism and illustrations of the suffering of Jewish Germans who learned that they rather were German Jews, if perceived as German at all. Some converted to open doors and achieve equality, as it seemed impossible to be both German and Jewish. Very few German Jews became Zionists.

Modern Judaism is described in the exhibition as analogous to Protestantism in relation to Catholocism.

The exhibition covers Berlin from 1890-1933 and shows the role of Jewish Germans in modernization of the new German state (founded only in 1871). The KaDeWe department store was depicted. The role played in theatre and other arts also was featured. The works of many Jewish artists working in the area of modern art was criticized as un-German.
For those who wanted a return to pre-modernity, the Jews were blamed for the ills of modernity.

Interestingly Zionists took the view that Jews should go to Palestine to become farmers and leave the roles they'd taken on in Europe. They thought eastern European Jews were more authentic and were critical of German and other western European Jews.

The Jewish role in the liberal movement for social justice in the face of accelerating change was also featured.

Jews fought enthusiastically for Germany in WWI. The post-war Weimar Republic granted Jews full equality. Yet anti-Semitism began to grow as well, with Jews blamed for more and more ills that affected people's lives such as dire economic conditions and the defeat in WWI. The greater the expansion of rights the greater the hostility grew.

When Hitler assumed power in 1933 anti-Semitism became official state policy. There are posters of boycotts against Jewish owned shops. Question: are boycotts of Israeli goods the same or are they more designed to pressure changes in state policy? In any event this marked the end of the movement for equality and the exhibition then explores what came next. Those who were able to leave did so until emigration was prohibited in October 1941.

While the Holocaust is covered the museum really does cover two thousand years of Jewish life in Germany. The last portion of the exhibition covers the post-war period.

We've had another full and exhausting day and will need time and discussion to absorb what we've seen.

Continuation of our Tour of Jewish Berlin-More Raw Notes



Ironically when Jews were forced to sell or abandon their property the clothing business was affected and there was a shortage of traditional German clothing like lederhausen. It just shows how much a part of the fabric of German life the Jewish community really was and how the Nazis didn't just exterminate a "foreign" community but part of the organic Germany.

Correction: the number of 200,000 represents the number of Jews in all of Germany. Only 11,000 are in Berlin but that is the biggest concentration of Jews.

We stopped for a quick lunch at a bagel place (Bagels & Bialy's)where I had a berry smoothie and Kim had a savoury tart with salad and humous. Carpe Diem is a company that makes organic lemonade type drinks but that isn't what I ordered. A bialy is a Russian flat pastry with various fillings.

After our brief lunch we went to the nearby Hackescher area which developed outside of the city walls. There are lots of beautiful courtyards. They served as a form or protection. There also is a lively market area in the area.

At this point the clouds lifted and it became quite hot in the mid-afternoon sun, but there was still somewhat of a breeze. We kept on, approaching Alexanderplatz which is located in the former medieval Berlin.

We saw the site of the first synagogue that was set up by the Jews that came to Berlin after 1671, following their earlier expulsion. They needed permission to build it and were subject to restrictions including as to height relevant to other structures. Before 1671 there were private synagogue like prayer rooms and some were big enough to accommodate large numbers. But it was significant that a public synagogue was allowed. The site was bombed during the last stages of the war and the rubble removed by the East German government. It wasn't affected by the earlier Kristallnacht.

The on site memorial on Rosenstrasse was done by an East German showing how non-Jewish women protested what the Nazis were done. Some of the women weren't considered Jewish under the Nazi racial laws which didn't recognize converts as Jews and many protesters wanted their Jewish husbands released. Amazingly many men indeed were released at a point in 1943 when 1,000 people were protesting. Most who were released survived the war.



This incident is another example of people standing up to the Nazi government who were not arrested or worse. You either can view this as a good thing or use it to ask why others didn't engage in the same sort of civil disobedience.
The story also is interesting because it took place at the time of the siege of Stalingrad when many German soldiers died for lack of supplies. The Holocaust was an important war aim and not incidental. Otherwise trains needed to supply soldiers who were freezing to death wouldn't have been used instead to transport Jewish civilians to the eastern death camps. So intense was Hitler's hatred of Jews that he compromised the lives of his own soldiers.

By the way the medieval Jewish community was expelled due to the blood libel that Jews killed Christian children to harvest their blood for use in making Passover matzo.

We then toured a museum in honour of Otto Weidt's Workshop for the blind. He employed many deaf and blind Jews during the war and tried to protect them, moving many into hiding. Some of the hiding spots are still visible. The exhibit has explanation is braille as well as in German and English.

Because Wiedt's business was for profit and arguably related to the war effort, he had some clout, and in one instance he traveled to Auschwitz and secured the release of a Jewish employee who had survived the selection process. In doing so he offered his brushes for sale to the camp administrators. Alice Licht survived the war and emigrated to the US afterwards. Another person he saved went to England and later to the US. She has since returned to Germany in her 90's.

He did have a circle of helpers in his effort. For example, some procured food and others provided shelter. Others warned him of pending roundups of Jews and still others provided false identity papers.


Of course others in hiding were denounced by their fellow citizens, arrested by the Gestapo and then deported and murdered.

Some of the museum comprises the original workshops and other portions have been added on.

Before leaving the area we explored a number of the courtyards that were full of shops and restaurants. Some were decorated in an art deco style and each one seemed to lead to another. Alex left us there for a bit to explore while he went to get the car.

At that point and with only a couple of minutes to spare I found the Kruck chocolate store. It all looked amazing but I was afraid it would melt if we walked around with it. So we would bought a bar of dark chocolate with chili to eat right now. Excellent with an after zing!

I'm now quite tired, but Alex is now dropping us off at the Jewish Museum where we will do a self-guided audio tour after he first orients us and explains the architecture. There will be some sites along the way and we also welcome some air conditioned time sitting in the car. (The museum also is air conditioned.) Apparently the guided tour is so good that it won an award so it's best to be refreshed to be able to absorb it.

We will make our way back to our hotel by subway from there. If we don't do it the museum now we will miss it altogether as tomorrow is our last full day and we are going to the Potsdam area where the various monarchs had their palaces.

Notes from Our Morning



I will clean this up later, and add photos too, but don't want to forget anything.

We started at Potsdam Square. It was all rebuilt as it was destroyed in WWII and was no man's land in Cold War. All rebuilt in last 10+ years. Wall went through it as per cobblestones. (We were there on our own yesterday on our way to the Tiergarden.)

There are many memorials to people who died trying to escape East Berlin, some with crosses.

The rebuilt Jewish community is imported mainly from Eastern Europe including Russia.

We stopped at Palais Ephraim. There were "Court Jews" loyal to the monarch, often bankers. The community depended on the goodwill of the king as Jews were not citizens until after the French Revolution. The building was totally destroyed but it was rebuilt and is now a museum.

Lapidarium is a museum of tombstones. That is where we were yesterday.

We saw a library focusing on victims of Stalinism in a neighbourhood reconstructed to look how it was in 1700's with cobblestone streets. We went to Lessing house. The name of the area is Nikolaiviertel.

Berlin is a Slavic word meaning in between the swaps of wet areas. The bear connotation actually is a mistake but there are lots of bears including a statue here. We saw the old seal of city of the united city and St. Nicholas Church. It is Lutheran and was tolerated by rulers to get rid of Rome.

The old Jewish area was outside the medieval city walls as it was cheaper than within city walls. Jews were allowed to live within the walls as of 1671 but you paid extra taxes if Jewish.

There is lots of construction in the old East Berlin where there was a ton (or more) of wartime rubble that was neglected in Communism. Now even the precast housing put up by the Communists also is coming down.

We saw the kosher grocery and Orthodox area.

The place we saw the first night near our hotel was a JCC and is run by Chabad.

There are armed guards outside the Orthodox centre. There are 200,000 Jews now instead of only 20,000.

The big synagogue became reform in 1869 and we saw Adath Israel as a breakaway synagogue. This is now a functioning synagogue. In 1969 a law was passed after an attempted attack by a far left terrorist group re: the liberation of Palestine-i t was an attempted bombing of a community centre-federal law requires police to guard all Jewish institutions.

German Zionists didn't so much want to build Israel as get Eastern European Jews in Berlin to go there. Kids-many left here as easier to get a single visa than a family one. But Ahawah home for children got many kids out before the war.

There are small brass plates on sidewalks outside homes where deported people lived. 10,000 plaques. 55,000 Berlin Jews were deported starting October 1941.

We saw an old dance hall that still is open.

We came upon a bakery from pre-Nazi period and now owned by a daughter. Baker ordered to bake bread for those being collected but made more than paid to bake so people had more. Also made Shabbat challah. Survived Communist period even when no private property.

We had a snack-Kim had an apple rhubarb thing and I had a raisin danish type thing. Alex had a cheesecake and poppy seed square. All were excellent. It is one of the few independent bakeries not part of a franchise.

30% of the population in the area was Jewish pre-war but now it isn't at all.

The Catholic hospital showed solidarity, gave out food and hid people. It still is a Catholic hospital. They didn't save a ton of people but the act of solidarity was important and also shows that not all Germans supported the Nazis.

There are still visible bullet holes in some houses from WWII from when the Red Army was fighting the Nazis-at the end of the war many kids were sacrificed by being armed as civilians.

We looked at the outside of today's Jewish high school. Re-opened in 1994 and now co-ed and not just for boys. Quiet today as summer vacation. Living community among the memorials. 450 kids most of whom are Jewish and they do accept others. Private from E120 per month only. German curriculum but have Hebrew too.

Mendelsohn founded the Jewish school in 1774 as first Jewish school to be more than religious education but secular/modern like math. Actually the first of its kind in Prussia altogether.

We saw the site of former home for aged but it has been turned into a memorial site (see photo of the sculpture of many people) as it became a collection site for deportation. "Never Forget, Be Aware of the War, Keep the Peace" plaque put up by East Germans. One of first plaques put up by East Germans-only in 1988, 50 years after Kristallnacht. First time Jews singled out and not just part of persecuted non-fascists. Perhaps just an attempt to use Jews to look reformist so as to attract foreign investment and save the state.

The building was destroyed by shell with middle missing. Plaques on side to mark names of those killed.

We visited the spot of the old cemetery. The Nazis leveled it but bodies are still buried without tombstones. Was already closed for new burials as it was full.

Regina Jonas was the first female rabbi and was ordained in 1935 in the nearby synagogue. She was deported to Theresienstadt (Terezin in Czech) and then to Auschwitz where she was murdered. She was a rabbi in Theresienstadt. She didn't leave because she lived with her sick mother.

New synagogue: front is a museum and memorial but no prayer hall in it anymore. It wasn't destroyed on Kristallnacht. There was a memorial plaque affixed during the centennial year of 1966 so the Communists put it up. They don't mention that it was the Communists who removed the prayer hall in 1958. Was a reform shul. There was a security check to enter and an admission fee. It had space for 3,000 people to serve the entire community and its various subsets even though no one congregation was that big. It was a symbol that Jews were part of the country.

They started renovating in 1989 as on the 50th anniversary of Kristallnacht there was an effort to remember. They found artifacts when they removed concrete from the war, including the eternal light.

The renovation isn't a complete rebuild as they wanted some of the destruction to be visible.

The synagogue wasn't destroyed on Kristallnacht. Krutzfeld was a police officer who received a warning a day beforehand that there would be a pogrom and Himmler told police not to intervene. The SS did most of the damage and didn't wear uniforms to make it look like a spontaneous people's uprising. Krutzfeld made sure nothing would take place in the synagogue that day. He saw the SS break in and start a fire and was able to find other police and he kicked out the SS. He wasn't arrested but had to resign his post in the area. He still received a letter signed by Hitler thanking him for his service to the German people and his pension. As Alex says, he really did provide a service to the German people which included Jews.

Question: who is responsible for the atrocities in WWII-the Nazis of Germans generally? This is a very difficult question. But in Krutzfeld's case there is an example where defying the Nazis didn't lead to imprisonment or worse, which both shows that not all Germans followed the Nazis but also that defying the Nazis may not have been as risky as some say. Krutzfeld didn't talk about his role at all.

A tour group from Israel is now visiting and the noise is deafening so it is hard to hear Alex. I thought we weren't allowed to take photos but they are so maybe I should?

As the war broke out the dome had to be painted black for air raid camouflage reasons but the request was made on Rosh Hashanah for political reasons.
The back of the synagogue shows columns outside that supported the original prayer hall, now destroyed. This area is now a memorial. There is a sports hall behind the site now used by the Jewish high school that we saw earlier.

There are street signs on the floor relating the objects displayed to their original location in the quarter.

Paradoxically after the Nazis came to power there was a revival of the community as it was what was available and could be trusted. Many assimilated Jews became Jewish in terms of identity, if not religion, at this time. The Nazis didn't mind this development as they wanted full segregation.

The Jewish museum was opened only four days before Hitler came to power and then was closed after Kristallnacht.

There is a photo of the outdoor 1939 Purim parade and there are visible police guards. We can't tell why police were there-to guard against attacks against children or to monitor and police the parade?

That's it for now.